The Most Controversial Baseball Umpires of All Time

Baseball is a game built on moments — walk-off home runs, no-hitters, and record-breaking plays. But sometimes, it’s the umpires who steal the spotlight. From missed calls that changed the course of championships to heated dugout confrontations, MLB umpiring controversies are as much a part of the sport’s history as the players themselves.

At Sport Displays, we believe those unforgettable moments — even the controversial ones — deserve to be remembered. Whether it’s a signed ball, a ticket stub, or a game-worn jersey, our custom display cases help fans preserve baseball history their way.

1. Ángel Hernández — Baseball’s Most Polarizing Umpire

Few names spark as much debate as Ángel Hernández. Over his 30-year career, Hernández became infamous for inconsistent strike zones and calls that seemed to defy replay. In one 2018 playoff game, four of his five calls at first base were overturned.

While he’s since retired, his name still trends anytime a questionable call hits social media. Love him or hate him, Hernández became a symbol of the tension between human error and technological precision — the kind of moment every fan remembers shouting at their TV about.

Preserve your favorite (or most frustrating) baseball memories with a premium jersey display mount that turns any collectible into a conversation piece.

2. Don Denkinger — The Call That Changed the 1985 World Series

Game 6 of the 1985 World Series. Bottom of the ninth. The St. Louis Cardinals were one out away from victory when first-base umpire Don Denkinger made one of the most infamous calls in baseball history — ruling Royals batter Jorge Orta safe when replays clearly showed otherwise.

That single call flipped the series. The Royals came back to win both the game and the championship. Denkinger faced a lifetime of backlash, but his moment remains a powerful reminder that umpires hold enormous influence over the game’s greatest stories.

If you’ve ever held onto a ticket stub or collectible from a game like that, give it the stage it deserves with a custom display frame — because every story deserves to be seen.

3. Joe West — “The Cowboy” Who Loved the Spotlight

Joe West wasn’t just an umpire — he was a character. Known for his big personality, confrontations with players, and country-music side gig, West officiated more games than any other ump in MLB history. But with that longevity came controversy: blown calls, bold opinions, and an ever-present camera lens.

West’s clashes with players like Bryce Harper and managers like Joe Torre made him part of baseball’s entertainment value. Whether fans cheered or booed, they always remembered “Cowboy Joe.”

For fans who love that side of the game — the drama, the emotion, the storytelling — Sport Displays offers the perfect way to immortalize those moments. Our jersey mounts and collectible displays make your fan cave as legendary as the game itself.

4. Jim Joyce — The Heartbreaking Missed Call

On June 2, 2010, Jim Joyce stood behind first base as Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga prepared to complete a perfect game. With two outs in the ninth, a ground ball rolled to first. The throw beat the runner — but Joyce called him safe.

Replays showed the runner was clearly out. The perfect game was gone. To his credit, Joyce immediately admitted his mistake and hugged Galarraga the next day in tears — a rare moment of vulnerability that baseball fans will never forget.

If you’re a fan of preserving iconic baseball history — good, bad, or bittersweet — visit TheSportDisplays.com to browse our baseball display mounts designed for jerseys, balls, and memorabilia that tell a story.

5. Pat Hoberg — Modern Controversy in the Digital Era

In 2025, MLB umpire Pat Hoberg was fired after violating the league’s gambling policy. While there was no proof of game manipulation, the incident underscored just how much scrutiny modern umpires face. In today’s age of AI strike zones and data analytics, even the slightest misstep can dominate headlines.

Umpiring has evolved — and so has fandom. More than ever, fans are collecting, sharing, and displaying the artifacts of the sport’s most debated moments. That’s exactly what inspired Sport Displays: giving collectors an elegant way to honor the game’s history, warts and all.

6. The Pine Tar Game — Chaos, Controversy, and George Brett’s Rage

On July 24, 1983, George Brett launched a go-ahead home run against the Yankees — only to have it nullified when umpires ruled there was too much pine tar on his bat. The image of Brett storming out of the dugout in rage is burned into baseball history.

The ruling was later overturned, but the chaos lives on in highlight reels and collector displays everywhere. If you’ve got a vintage bat, signed ball, or replica of this legendary moment, Sport Displays can help you showcase it in style.

Why Fans Love Controversy — and Why It Belongs on Display

Controversy fuels conversation. It keeps the game alive long after the final pitch. Every disputed call, emotional ejection, and viral replay adds another layer to baseball’s incredible storytelling tradition.

At Sport Displays, we help fans turn that passion into something tangible — through custom jersey mounts, shadow boxes, and memorabilia displays built for collectors who love every side of the game: the glory, the heartbreak, and the controversy.

If you’re ready to turn your favorite baseball memories into a professional-grade display, visit www.TheSportDisplays.com today.